In Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure, I make gold through Fishing, Mining, Smithing, Woodcutting and Thieving. Some methods earn more at lower levels, while others become much better as I unlock new skills, upgrades and bonuses. In this guide, I compare the best money-making methods, show how much gold each path earns, and explain which activities are worth using at different levels.
What Method Earns the Most
I compare five new characters, each following one path and always choosing the best-paying action they unlocked. The game only runs one action at a time, so I need to choose a path and stick with it.
| Path | After 5 hours | After 24 hours | After 72 hours | After 300 hours | Level after 300 hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fishing | 60,000 | 420,000 | 2,054,000 | 23,618,000 | Fishing 99 |
| Woodcutting | 61,000 | 391,000 | 1,522,000 | 10,671,000 | Woodcutting 92 |
| Mining and Smithing | 74,000 | 423,000 | 1,364,000 | 7,819,000 | Mining 83, Smithing 83 |
| Thieving | 69,000 | 389,000 | 1,302,000 | 6,208,000 | Thieving 85 |
| Mining | 43,000 | 255,000 | 893,000 | 5,915,000 | Mining 92 |
Mining and Smithing earns the most on the first day because finished gear sells for much more than the ore used to make it. However, I switch between mining, smelting and smithing myself. Fishing catches up at around 24 hours and then pulls ahead. It also uses one action that I leave running.
How Bonuses Change
I look at Shop tool upgrades, Mastery Guild ranks, Astrology nodes, pets and skilling outfits as permanent bonuses. They help a chain of actions more than a single action because the same bonus applies at every step. Preservation on Smithing saves bars when I smith and ore when I smelt. Pickaxe heads make mining ore faster. Fishing has fewer steps to improve, with its waiting time, doubling chance and special items.
The next table shows which path earns the most if I start with half or all of these bonuses from the first minute. A real character will usually fall somewhere in between. I use the half-bonus row as an example of someone who buys each tool upgrade as it unlocks.
| With | The path that has earned the most |
|---|---|
| No bonuses | Thieving until hour 2, then Mining and Smithing until hour 24, then Fishing |
| Half the bonuses | Thieving until hour 32, then Mining and Smithing until hour 96, then Fishing |
| Every bonus | Thieving until hour 104, then Woodcutting until hour 120, then Fishing |
I also compare the best-paying item or action in each skill with every skill at 99. These figures are GP per hour.
| Skill | No bonuses | Half the bonuses | Every bonus |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crafting | Silver Diamond Amulet: 51,782 | Silver Diamond Amulet: 114,605 | Diamond: 372,006 |
| Cooking | Whale: 129,133 | Whale: 217,969 | Whale: 359,515 |
| Fishing | Deep Blue: 165,738 | Deep Blue: 229,635 | Deep Blue: 311,220 |
| Fletching | Hard Oak Bow: 52,797 | Redwood Bow: 105,091 | Diamond Bolts: 258,123 |
| Woodcutting | Redwood Tree: 50,254 | Redwood Tree: 109,210 | Redwood Tree: 192,349 |
| Smithing | Dragon Dagger: 33,026 | Dragon Platebody: 91,843 | Dragon Platebody: 178,943 |
| Thieving | Craftsman: 25,255 | Herbalist: 61,829 | Capital Seed Stall: 150,169 |
| Mining | Jadestone Vein: 33,896 | Jadestone Vein: 81,473 | Jadestone Vein: 147,087 |
| Runecrafting | Soul Rune: 5,112 | Soul Rune: 29,338 | Soul Rune: 74,176 |
| Firemaking | Redwood Log: 3,494 | Redwood Log: 4,136 | Redwood Log: 4,637 |
Diamond is cutting the Uncut Diamonds I mine. It jumps in the last column because the Major 1 node of the Hyden constellation in Astrology adds a gem to every cut. Whale comes from cooking Raw Whales caught at Deep Blue.
Potions, food, bonfires and rare events add more gold, but I haven’t included them. Every bonus uses the best item for that bonus separately, so treat this as the ceiling.
The Fishing Ladder
I start at Shallow Pools and move to the next fishing spot as I reach the required level. The Hours in column shows how long I have been fishing when I reach each step. I use the Stay for column to see how long I remain at that spot before moving on.
| Start at | Hours in | Do this | GP per hour | Stay for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fishing 1 | Start | Shallow Pools | 3,006 | 6 min |
| Fishing 6 | 6 min | Calm Shallows | 5,528 | 31 min |
| Fishing 18 | 37 min | Dock Waters | 7,612 | 20 min |
| Fishing 23 | 58 min | Pebble Bank | 13,150 | 2 h 36 min |
| Fishing 39 | 3 h 34 min | Rapid Runs | 14,046 | 3 h 53 min |
| Fishing 49 | 7 h 27 min | Shimmering Depths | 15,428 | 4 h 17 min |
| Fishing 55 | 12 h | Sea Edge | 21,111 | 15 h |
| Fishing 67 | 27 h | Gusty Cliffside | 26,074 | 13 h |
| Fishing 73 | 40 h | Vibrant Shallows | 35,779 | 17 h |
| Fishing 78 | 58 h | Glowing Rift | 41,920 | 19 h |
| Fishing 82 | 77 h | Tuna Run | 54,085 | 44 h |
| Fishing 88 | 121 h | Shark Cove | 79,234 | 58 h |
| Fishing 93 | 179 h | Luminous Abyss | 102,276 | 31 h |
| Fishing 95 | 210 h | Bountiful Corals | 102,665 | 59 h |
| Fishing 98 | 269 h | Deep Blue | 165,738 | From here on |
These rates leave out drops that appear less than once an hour, such as the Torn Ancient Sailcloth from Gusty Cliffside. A lucky run earn more.
The Thug Chest Key
I open a locked chest with a Lockpick or its own key. The Thug Chest Key adds 500 Stealth to the Locked Thug Chest. From Thieving 10, this means I never fail the chest or take damage from it.
The chest earns about 66,000 GP per hour on average and gives 17,100 XP per hour. Around half of the gold comes from coins and common loot. The rest comes from four or five rare drops each hour.
The key has two halves. I get one as a rare drop from the Thug Chief. The other comes from the chest itself, so I keep opening it with Lockpicks until it appears. Each attempt uses a Lockpick, whether it works or not. Thugs drop Lockpicks, and the main quest The Path to Melvor gives me 1,000.
I need to be careful when Thieving because getting knocked out destroys an item from a random toolbelt slot. This include the key.
My Best Method at Each Level
I compare the best-paying method I use at each level, with every skill at the level shown and no bonuses. For crafted items, I include the time needed to gather and make every ingredient from nothing.
| With every skill at | Best method | Levels it needs | GP per hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Citizen (Thieving) | Thieving 1 | 6,805 |
| 5 | Thug (Thieving) | Thieving 5 | 9,616 |
| 15 | Iron 2H Sword (Smithing) | Smithing 15, Mining 10 | 12,372 |
| 20 | Silver Topaz Amulet (Crafting) | Crafting 18, Mining 18, Smithing 18 | 23,221 |
| 40 | Silver Sapphire Amulet (Crafting) | Crafting 32, Mining 32, Smithing 18 | 23,356 |
| 60 | Gold Ruby Ring (Crafting) | Crafting 58, Mining 47, Smithing 38 | 24,058 |
| 70 | Dawnsteel Dagger (Smithing) | Smithing 70, Mining 70 | 30,378 |
| 80 | Glowing Rift (Fishing) | Fishing 78 | 41,920 |
| 90 | Shark Cove (Fishing) | Fishing 88 | 79,234 |
| 99 | Deep Blue (Fishing) | Fishing 98 | 165,738 |
Thieving only unlocks at Cooking 10. On a brand-new character, I start with Stone gear from Smithing, which earns about 4,000 GP per hour.
The full table ranks 371 methods. It shows the levels each method needs and its GP per hour with no bonuses, half the bonuses and all bonuses. I also include the Mining and Smithing, Woodcutting and Thieving ladders, along with the time needed to reach each level. The full table is too wide to fit in a Steam guide.
Gold That Counts Towards Unlocks
I need to sell items to unlock the Shop and Ranching. The Shop opens after I earn 250 GP from selling items. Ranching needs 20,000 GP from sales and 200 Normal Logs cut. Coins from Thieving, combat and quests do not count towards either total, so I make sure to sell my loot when working towards Ranching.